A Supreme Court decree turns a Rio Grande dispute into a water-accounting plan
An interstate compact dispute ended with agreed rules using water gauges and a delivery index to measure compliance.
In most Supreme Court disputes, the final document answers a question brought up from a lower court. In Texas v. New Mexico, the justices entered a final consent decree in a case that began on their own original docket. The order adopts an accounting framework to measure deliveries under the Rio Grande Compact among Texas, New Mexico and Colorado.
The compact, approved by Congress in 1939, apportions waters of the Rio Grande among the states. The May 26 decree followed a fourth interim report from Special Master D. Brooks Smith. It resolves the compact apportionment dispute on terms agreed to by the states and discharges the special master.
The decree defines the Effective El Paso Index and separates the delivery measurement from the annual delivery obligation. Its calculations draw in part on the official flows at the Caballo Dam and El Paso gauges. Among other adjustments, the delivery measure excludes deliveries to Mexico under the separate 1906 convention and incorporates estimated volumes of depletion in the Texas part of the Mesilla Basin. The difference between measured delivery and obligation records an annual departure, which can be positive or negative.
The terms give legal significance to the way agencies measure and account for water. A river gauge reading is fundamentally a hydrological observation. In this decree, identified readings combine with documented adjustments to produce a number the states use to evaluate performance under the agreement.
The decision is a final consent decree for the dispute, rather than a new generic rule for all interstate rivers. Readers seeking to understand what counts as a shortfall need to consult the actual appendices. Those pages set out the index, the exceptions and the geographical scope against which the states will measure compliance.