Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Opinion analysis

Supreme Court closes two routes to liability in Cisco surveillance case

The justices declined to recognize new Alien Tort Statute causes of action and rejected aiding-and-abetting liability under a separate torture law.

The U.S. Supreme Court Building at dusk.
Context photograph. Noclip · Public domain. See Image Credits.

Plaintiffs alleged that Chinese authorities persecuted them because of their religious beliefs and used surveillance technology developed by Cisco to identify and apprehend them. On June 23, the Supreme Court addressed whether two federal statutes support the kinds of civil claims they asserted against the company and certain executives.

The Alien Tort Statute gives federal courts jurisdiction over certain tort claims by non-U.S. plaintiffs alleging violations of international law. The district court dismissed the claims, and the Ninth Circuit allowed important parts of the case to proceed. Under the approach described in Sosa v. Alvarez-Machain, the appeals court thought it could recognize aiding-and-abetting liability in these circumstances.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s majority opinion held that federal courts may not create new causes of action for violations of international norms under the Alien Tort Statute. The Court emphasized Congress’s role in creating such liability and the practical consequences of judicial decisions that reach conduct abroad. That holding foreclosed the asserted aiding-and-abetting route on the first statute.

A separate claim rested on the Torture Victim Protection Act. The Court interpreted Congress’s provision imposing liability on a person who subjects another to torture as not encompassing the aiding-and-abetting claim brought against the Cisco executives. The two holdings arise from different legal questions. The first concerns judicial creation of a remedy. The second concerns what an existing statutory remedy covers.

The Court reversed and returned the case. Separate writings disagreed with the majority’s approach in different respects. The outcome addresses whether the plaintiffs could bring these claims under the laws invoked. It is not a factual determination about how the system was built, whether the government used it as described, or whether the alleged persecution occurred.

Source Documents

  1. Supreme Court opinion and separate writings
  2. Supreme Court docket
Share by email Corrections policy

Related reporting