Fourth Circuit says Baltimore’s real-time cellphone tracking was a search
The court set a precedent on cell-site simulators and ruled that the case could not proceed against officers because the rule was unclear in 2014.
The Fourth Circuit held on September 24 that police conduct a Fourth Amendment search when they use a cell-site simulator to track a phone in real time. The published opinion arose out of a Baltimore case, but its rule reaches beyond the city. Kerron Andrews, the person tracked, lost his civil appeal because the legal rule had not been clearly established when detectives used the device in 2014 and the record did not show a basis for municipal liability.
Detectives obtained an arrest warrant and a separate court order for information from Andrews’s phone provider. The provider’s information narrowed the search to several blocks. A cell-site simulator then identified the phone at a specific home. The use of that device was disclosed to the defense later in the criminal proceeding. Maryland courts suppressed evidence, the criminal charges were dismissed and Andrews brought a civil rights suit seeking damages.
Judge Nicole Berner’s majority opinion found a reasonable expectation of privacy in a phone’s precise, real-time location when law enforcement uses a device to elicit the phone’s signals. It distinguished police actively obtaining the location from police observing what a person knowingly exposes in public. The court concluded that use of this technology requires a valid warrant. The panel did not decide whether the particular pen-register order in Andrews’s case satisfied the warrant requirement.
The detectives nevertheless received qualified immunity because existing precedent had not clearly put them on notice of that Fourth Amendment rule at the time. The panel also upheld immunity on the state constitutional claims and concluded that Andrews had not established a city policy, custom or practice causing the alleged violation for purposes of municipal liability. The majority also cautioned that private nondisclosure obligations cannot justify withholding important information from a court.
The majority put its ruling in the context of Supreme Court decisions about cellphone location data and digital privacy. The device here identified a phone’s location in real time by obtaining a response directly from the phone, rather than relying exclusively on a carrier’s historical records. In the majority’s view, the precise information this can reveal and the phone owner’s lack of a meaningful choice in transmitting the signal supported treating the technique as a search.
The concurrence underscores the narrower route available to courts in qualified-immunity cases. Judge Quattlebaum reasoned that the qualified-immunity question disposed of the federal damages claim without deciding the new technology question, especially because the majority declined to resolve the validity of the order used by police.
Judge Toby Heytens joined the precedential majority opinion. Judge A. Marvin Quattlebaum Jr. agreed with the judgment and parts of the reasoning but would have resolved qualified immunity without deciding whether the device use was a search. The circuit affirmed summary judgment with no remand. The holding matters prospectively even though it did not produce a damages recovery in this case.