Why a Missouri Roundup verdict turned on a federally approved label
The Supreme Court ruled that federal pesticide law displaces a Missouri claim requiring a cancer warning on the EPA-approved Roundup label.
A Missouri jury found Monsanto liable on a failure-to-warn theory after John Durnell alleged that about two decades of Roundup use had caused his non-Hodgkin lymphoma. The Supreme Court reversed the state appellate ruling on June 25, 2026. Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s majority opinion treated the dispute as a question about which level of government can impose a specific label requirement.
The Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act prohibits states from imposing pesticide labeling or packaging requirements that differ from, or go beyond, requirements established under federal law. The Court treated a state tort duty as a labeling requirement when the liability theory demands a different warning. Missouri’s obligation, as Durnell sought to enforce it, would have required adding a cancer warning to the label itself.
The majority emphasized that EPA approves the actual label and that manufacturers generally must use it until EPA approves or requires a change. The agency had repeatedly approved the relevant label without a cancer warning. The Court saw a parallel with its earlier medical device case, Riegel v. Medtronic, where product-specific federal approval displaced conflicting liability theories under comparable statutory language.
Durnell argued that both legal systems demanded adequate warnings and that federal registration was only initial evidence of compliance. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, joined by Justice Neil Gorsuch, dissented. The dissent read the federal statute differently and warned against treating registration as though its approval could itself establish a preemptive requirement. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote separately in concurrence.
The opinion addresses the label duty underlying this particular claim. Federal pesticide law still provides for later changes to labels and ongoing agency oversight, and the ruling’s application to a different liability theory depends on the duty that theory would impose. The Court sent the case back to Missouri rather than issuing a scientific finding about what caused Durnell’s illness.