Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Opinion analysis

What a fair tax auction owes a homeowner after the sale

A tax-assessed value of $194,400 and an auction price of $76,008 put the federal measure of compensation at issue.

The U.S. Supreme Court Building at dusk.
Context photograph. Noclip · Public domain. See Image Credits.

Isabella County sold the Pung family’s Michigan home after $2,241.93 in unpaid real-property taxes. The county’s assessment put the house at $194,400, but the public auction produced $76,008. The federal question was what the government could keep and what figure should determine compensation for what it took.

The Supreme Court held that the price at a fairly conducted tax sale, rather than an estimate of ordinary market value, supplies the compensation baseline. That conclusion leaves in place the underlying principle that government must return surplus value of the kind realized at the auction after satisfying the lawful debt. The judgment, issued June 23, vacated the Sixth Circuit’s decision and sent the case back.

Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion traced the practice of selling property to collect taxes and returning the surplus to the former owner. The Court treated a tax sale of one parcel as different from ordinary eminent domain and gave weight to a long history of tax collection through auction. It also recognized a practical difference between an appraisal and the amount buyers offer at a forced sale.

The Court rejected the separate theory that the county violated the Eighth Amendment’s Excessive Fines Clause by failing to compensate the estate for ordinary market value. The majority’s premise was a fairly conducted tax sale fitting the historical tax-collection practice. It did not resolve new contentions about the fairness of the procedures used in this sale. The Sixth Circuit may take up those contentions on remand to the extent the litigant preserved them.

Pung follows Tyler v. Hennepin County, which recognized a constitutional claim over surplus tax-sale proceeds. The cases concern two different points in the same transaction. Tyler addressed the government’s claim to keep a realized surplus. Pung addresses the measure of that surplus when the estate believes a fair sale would value the property differently from an appraisal. A reliable record of notice and bidding may matter when the fairness of an auction is disputed.

Source Documents

  1. Supreme Court opinion and separate writings
  2. Supreme Court docket
Share by email Corrections policy

Related reporting