Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Opinion analysis

North Myrtle Beach prevails in dune walkover permit appeal

The property owner’s proposed dune crossing did not comply with a mandatory design condition, so the owner lacked a protected entitlement to city approval.

Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia.
Context photograph. dctim1 · CC BY-SA 2.0. See Image Credits.

The Fourth Circuit upheld North Myrtle Beach’s victory in a federal dispute over proposed construction on beachfront property. White Cap Beach House had state coastal permits, but it argued that the city violated its right to due process by denying separate building permits. On November 13, an appellate panel concluded that the owner had no constitutionally protected entitlement to city approval of its submitted plans.

The owner sought to build a dune walkover, a gazebo and other structures. The state permits incorporated a requirement that a dune crossing run perpendicular to the shore, subject to a disability-access exception. The city’s coastal overlay ordinance incorporated the same design rules. White Cap acknowledged that its proposed crossing was angled and did not invoke the accessibility exception. It challenged the permit denials internally and then took the dispute to court.

Under the circuit’s land-use cases, a constitutionally protected interest generally requires more than a strong expectation of approval. The question is whether the permitting authority lacked discretion to deny the application under the governing law. The panel held that the city retained discretion here because White Cap had not met a mandatory condition. The fact that a gazebo can be a permitted use did not resolve the matter because the same applications also sought permission to build the angled crossing.

The panel also rejected the argument that the state’s issuance of its permits prevented the city from enforcing its own ordinance. The state permits made their written conditions controlling and said applicants still had to comply with local requirements. The city neither revoked a state permit nor changed a state condition. The appeals court resolved the threshold property-interest issue and did not reach arguments about other grounds for denial or how the city ran its administrative appeal.

The owner argued that an angled crossing might reduce disturbance to the dunes. The panel explained that minimizing environmental disturbance and building a crossing perpendicular to shore were separate regulatory conditions. Compliance with one condition did not excuse the other. The court also declined to treat willingness to alter the construction later as equivalent to submitting plans that satisfied the existing permit conditions.

The district court had resolved the federal claims and declined to retain supplemental jurisdiction over the state-law claims. The federal appeal addressed the claimed deprivation of a protected property interest. The opinion does not decide whether a different, conforming submission would receive municipal approval or resolve every state-law dispute about the project.

Judges Robert King and Allison Jones Rushing and district judge Mark S. Davis, sitting by designation, issued the unanimous opinion. It is unpublished and nonprecedential. The panel affirmed the federal judgment without ordering further proceedings.

Source Documents

  1. Official Fourth Circuit opinion PDF
  2. National Archives, Fourteenth Amendment
Share by email Corrections policy

Related reporting