Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Opinion analysis

Fourth Circuit upholds Charleston-area wetlands permit after reviewing alternatives

The panel upheld the federal approval for Cainhoy after finding that the Corps reasonably explained why alternatives would be impracticable or more damaging.

Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia.
Context photograph. dctim1 · CC BY-SA 2.0. See Image Credits.

A federal wetlands permit for a large Charleston-area development survived a challenge in the Fourth Circuit on October 23. A unanimous panel found that the Army Corps of Engineers supplied a reasonable explanation for choosing the Cainhoy plan over alternative layouts and sites. The court also corrected the district court’s interpretation of which statute authorized the challenge, while leaving its judgment in favor of the Corps intact.

The Clean Water Act’s Section 404 permitting process required the Corps to assess practicable alternatives. The selected Cainhoy plan would affect 181.5 acres of wetlands. The South Carolina Coastal Conservation League, Charleston Waterkeeper and South Carolina Wildlife Federation argued that the Corps’s alternatives review was too narrow, particularly because a set of alternatives prepared for them would directly affect between zero and 13.2 acres. The district court concluded that the agency acted reasonably and entered summary judgment against the groups.

Judge Stephanie Thacker’s opinion described an agency review that reached nine off-site alternatives, four alternative layouts for the property, the conservation groups’ proposal and a scenario in which the permit was denied. Off-site parcels were unsuitable for reasons including availability, location and infrastructure. Four alternative layouts had larger estimated wetlands impacts. The Corps also found that the configuration of wetlands and uplands on the property limited how much impact could be avoided while building the planned community.

The groups’ proposal had a much smaller immediate wetlands footprint, but it contemplated development on roughly 1,000 of about 9,000 acres and did not protect the rest against future development. The Corps warned that separately developing the remainder could affect more wetlands and that the proposal served a different mix of residential and development objectives. The panel held that the Corps connected its decision to the evidence and adequately addressed the alternatives. It did not substitute its preferred land-use plan.

The agency also examined a scenario in which none of the proposed work was authorized. It reasoned that later development of smaller parcels might produce greater cumulative wetlands impacts and lose the benefit of coordinated conservation. The court credited that explanation because the agency’s analysis connected the layout, the prospect of further development and the proposed mitigation to the way the permit would actually work.

The jurisdiction discussion has consequences for future challenges. A citizen suit under the Clean Water Act and a final-agency-action challenge under the Administrative Procedure Act rest on different grants of authority. The panel distinguished cases about failure to perform a nondiscretionary duty from one challenging a specific discretionary permit determination already made by the Corps.

The published, precedential opinion found that the Administrative Procedure Act supplied the route for reviewing this final, discretionary permitting decision. The Clean Water Act citizen-suit theory was the wrong route on these facts. The error did not change the result because the district court applied the same arbitrary-and-capricious standard. Judges G. Steven Agee and Nicole Berner joined Thacker without a separate opinion. The decision reaches the merits of the permit challenge and affirms without a remand.

Source Documents

  1. Official Fourth Circuit opinion PDF
  2. 33 U.S.C. § 1344, dredged or fill material permits
  3. 5 U.S.C. § 706, scope of judicial review
Share by email Corrections policy

Related reporting