Pretrial detainee’s medical-care case returns to a North Carolina court
A panel ordered a fresh look at the jail medical-care claims because binding circuit law now uses an objective test for people in pretrial detention.
The Fourth Circuit revived Gerald Hopper’s jail medical-care lawsuit on November 13 because the district court used a legal standard that circuit precedent later displaced. The panel sent the matter back to a federal judge in Charlotte to consider the allegations under the Fourteenth Amendment standard now applied to pretrial detainees. The judges did not decide that Hopper received constitutionally inadequate care.
Hopper was scheduled for surgery before he entered the Mecklenburg County Detention Center. While detained, he reported pain and bleeding, difficulty obtaining medical supplies and the need for the previously scheduled procedure. According to the appellate opinion, jail medical staff considered the operation non-emergency and declined a referral during the detention. Hopper had the procedure after his release. His suit alleged deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, including a policy that allegedly led to denial of the surgery.
The district court granted summary judgment under circuit law that applied the same subjective approach used for convicted prisoners’ Eighth Amendment claims. That approach generally required an official’s actual awareness of both a serious medical need and the risk created by the response to it. In Short v. Hartman, the Fourth Circuit later held that the Fourteenth Amendment permits a pretrial detainee’s claim under an objective test. Both sides agreed that the earlier standard had been displaced.
The unsigned panel opinion left application of that standard to the trial court in the first instance. The related claim about an official policy also returns on remand. The panel suggested that the court consider appointing counsel in light of the legal issues and possible gaps in the record. The suggestion was discretionary, and the judges did not reopen separate claims that were outside the appeal.
The court’s instruction matters to which facts will matter at the next stage. The earlier judgment focused on what individual staff members actually understood, while the later circuit precedent requires an objective assessment of the response to the risk. A conclusion about one did not allow the appeals court to settle the other without the district court first considering the record.
Hopper started the lawsuit representing himself while detained. On appeal, the court appointed counsel through an appellate clinic. Its suggestion of counsel on remand reflects the distinction between briefing an intervening legal ruling and gathering or developing evidence needed to litigate a constitutional claim in the district court.
Judges G. Steven Agee, Stephanie Thacker and Nicole Berner issued the unanimous decision. It is unpublished and nonbinding, while the precedent it directs the district court to apply is a published decision. The judgment has been vacated, and the question of liability remains open on remand.