Fourth Circuit affirms Medicare genetic-testing fraud conviction
A former telehealth contractor argued that trial rulings prevented him from showing he acted in good faith. The appeals court found no reversible error.
The Fourth Circuit upheld a North Carolina physician assistant’s Medicare fraud convictions and six-year prison sentence on August 12. The case involved genetic tests ordered through a remote telehealth job. The appellate judges analyzed the evidence of the defendant’s knowledge as well as his argument that limits on documents and witnesses made it unfairly difficult to present his defense.
Colby Joyner reviewed patient files and signed orders for hundreds of Medicare beneficiaries, according to the opinion. Laboratories billed Medicare more than $10 million for more than 14,600 tests on the orders, figures that describe submitted claims rather than what Medicare paid. Joyner testified that he relied on more experienced professionals and did not think the work violated Medicare rules. A jury convicted him of health care fraud and making false statements relating to health care matters.
Judge Julius Richardson concluded that jurors had enough evidence to infer knowledge or willful blindness. The jury heard that Joyner had spoken to only about 20 of the 607 people for whom he signed orders and that he did not use the results, despite written representations about using them in clinical decisions. The panel said Joyner’s challenges to how the jury understood the paperwork went to the weight of the evidence, which the jury was entitled to assess.
The judges also upheld the district court’s use of Evidence Rule 403 to exclude internal compliance material that Joyner had not received or reviewed. The court found that its limited value could reasonably be outweighed by the risk of distracting or misleading jurors. Four subpoenaed witnesses invoked the Fifth Amendment. The panel upheld the district court’s witness-specific assessment of their risk of self-incrimination. It assumed, without deciding, that a rebuttal remark and part of a jury instruction were improper and concluded they were harmless even when considered together.
The panel treated the prosecution’s evidence of fraud as separate from the question of what the employer thought about its compliance at the corporate level. Among the records Joyner wanted to introduce were company policies, internal emails and a lawyer’s opinion. The court reasoned that an attorney’s letter to the company would not supply the legal standard the jury was to apply and could confuse that task.
The circuit also rejected the sentencing challenge. It found the loss estimate sufficiently supported and declined to decide a contested sentencing theory based on special skill because Joyner did not challenge a separate, independent finding that he had abused a position of trust. That portion of the decision turned on what had been preserved for appeal.
Judges Robert King and Stephanie Thacker joined the published, precedential opinion without separate writings. The panel reached the merits of the appeal, although it left some alternative questions unresolved. It affirmed the convictions and sentence without a remand. The decision turns on the prosecution’s evidence about this defendant’s work and state of mind.