Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Docket Update

Arlington wins request to halt work on proposed Memorial Circle arch

A federal judge in Alexandria granted Arlington County’s request for preliminary relief on Nov. 20, citing likely disruption to emergency routes and questions over congressional approval for the proposed 250-foot arch.

Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia.
Context photograph. dctim1 · CC BY-SA 2.0. See Image Credits.

U.S. District Judge Leonie M. Brinkema granted Arlington County’s request for a preliminary injunction in its challenge to the proposed 250-foot arch at Memorial Circle. In a Nov. 20 memorandum opinion, the judge said the court would bar the National Park Service and the other defendants from taking steps to begin construction. The site is at the western end of Arlington Memorial Bridge, near Arlington National Cemetery. The preliminary ruling allows the lawsuit over the federal approval to continue.

Arlington filed suit on Oct. 8 and amended its complaint on Nov. 6. The County Board challenged the Park Service’s approval under the Administrative Procedure Act. Federal defendants disputed the county’s standing and argued that Alexandria was an improper venue because the dispute involved real property. Brinkema concluded that the case concerns the legality of an agency action, rather than ownership of the site. She also found that the prospect of changed traffic patterns and increased demands on emergency services gave Arlington a concrete interest in the case.

Whether the arch qualifies as a commemorative work was one of the key issues. Federal defendants argued that the design looked to the future and that a 1925 law authorizing the bridge project provided authority for the proposed work. The judge noted that the Park Service’s own environmental review described the arch as honoring the nation’s 250th anniversary. She concluded that the county was likely to prevail on its claim that Congress had not specifically authorized this structure. The earlier plan contemplated two columns, and the opinion found that the new arch would differ substantially in scale and design.

The injunction analysis also addressed when the county would need to act. The judge reasoned that Arlington would have to divert staff and resources to emergency response routes and traffic planning as soon as the defendants began preparing for construction. In balancing the competing interests, the court found it preferable to preserve existing conditions while the case moves forward. The November opinion addresses preliminary relief, with the underlying legal claims still to be resolved.

Source Documents

  1. Nov. 20 federal memorandum opinion, ECF No. 30 (PDF)
  2. Arlington County’s Oct. 8 filing announcement
  3. Official Eastern District of Virginia case access (PACER sign-in)
Share by email Corrections policy

Comments

0

Leave a comment

Related reporting