Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Opinion analysis

Judge leaves disputed role in luxury-car lending case for a fact-finder

The Norfolk court found competing evidence about an investor recruiter’s knowledge and involvement. It granted him judgment on a separate claim tied to whether he benefited from the specific loans.

Storage boxes in a National Archives stack area.
Context photograph. National Archives at College Park · U.S. public domain. See Image Credits.

A federal judge in Norfolk kept civil racketeering and fraud-related claims against Rhyan Finch in a lawsuit over loans that were supposed to finance luxury-car purchases. U.S. District Judge Elizabeth W. Hanes ruled Nov. 4 that the evidence could support different conclusions about his role. She granted him judgment on unjust enrichment because the plaintiffs did not show he benefited from the particular loans in dispute.

AASK Lending and Norm Gonzalez allege that funds were supposed to finance wholesale purchases, with profits generated by reselling the cars. According to the opinion, earlier loans did return the expected profit, but five made in April and May 2025 went unpaid. The court's ruling covers Finch’s civil liability. It does not determine that his conduct amounted to a crime.

For the federal racketeering claim, Hanes looked at whether Finch may have participated in directing the enterprise’s affairs. Evidence he pointed to included his own losses, messages suggesting he believed the operation was genuine, and steps he took to discourage further investment when he learned more. The plaintiffs pointed to his extensive communication with the operator, payments for investor referrals generally and discussions about expanding operations. Hanes concluded a jury could draw competing inferences from that record about what he knew and whether he knowingly agreed to engage in the conduct alleged.

The unjust-enrichment claim presented a different question. General evidence that Finch received referral fees did not show he received a fee or other benefit from the five loans at issue. The absence of evidence on that element allowed the court to resolve the claim as a matter of law without choosing whose account of the wider operation to believe.

For the remaining claims addressed by the motion, the November decision preserves the issues for further proceedings. It illustrates why courts may weigh the legal sufficiency of one claim while leaving related factual disputes unresolved. The motion was Finch’s, and the order did not resolve claims against all other defendants.

Source Documents

  1. Filed district court opinion, ECF No. 151 (PDF)
  2. Court opinion text and docket metadata
  3. Federal racketeering statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1962
Share by email Corrections policy

Related reporting