GAO leaves Alexandria firm’s DHS geospatial-services award in place
Two Northern Virginia companies competed for the DHS work. The agency found their proposals technically comparable and selected the lower-priced one.
A competition to provide geospatial technology support at the Department of Homeland Security became a bid dispute between two Northern Virginia firms. Integrity Management Consulting, of McLean, challenged the agency’s call order to ASET Partners, of Alexandria. The Government Accountability Office rejected the remaining challenges in August, dismissing some arguments without ruling on their merits and denying others after review.
DHS issued the solicitation to participants in an existing multiple-award arrangement. It ranked technical approach first and treated the combined non-price factors as significantly more important than price. It nevertheless reserved flexibility to determine best value. The record describes an initial order to Integrity, earlier litigation by ASET and corrective action leading to reevaluation and selection of ASET.
In the subsequent protest, Integrity argued that DHS had failed to recognize additional strengths in its quotation and assessed the companies unequally. GAO dismissed certain arguments as late because the information needed to raise them was already available. It considered other arguments on the record and concluded that DHS had evaluated the relevant features reasonably and within the stated criteria.
GAO also upheld the agency’s comparison of price and technical merit. The decision recognized that DHS considered specific strengths and differences before judging the two offers relatively equal overall on non-price factors. It was then reasonable for the selection official to prefer the lower price. Technical equivalence in this context describes a comparative evaluation, rather than an assertion that both firms offered identical methods or staff.
The result illustrates the difference between the listed order of procurement factors and the role each plays in a particular competition. Even when technical merits carry more weight, price can make the difference if evaluators reasonably document why the technical differences do not separate the bidders.