Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Reporting

GAO finds two evaluation errors in a Transportation Department audit-services award

The watchdog found errors in the review of staffing and price but recommended reimbursing the challenger instead of disturbing a contract already under way.

Washington Metro station sign in Bethesda, Maryland.
Context photograph. Chris Spielmann, National Cancer Institute · Public domain. See Image Credits.

The Government Accountability Office sustained an accounting firm’s protest of a Transportation Department order for internal-controls services. In its November 9 decision, it found that the Office of the Secretary of Transportation had misread part of the staffing requirement and incorrectly concluded that Castro & Company had failed to provide the single fixed price required in the solicitation.

The staffing dispute turned on the difference between people designated as key and additional employees available for a surge in workload. The solicitation left it to bidders to identify essential personnel. Castro supplied résumés for the three people it identified as key. Evaluators faulted the company for not supplying résumés for other people. GAO concluded that the agency’s requirement, read as a whole, did not reasonably put bidders on notice that those other résumés were mandatory.

On price, the agency found that Castro had not supplied a single fixed figure covering two fiscal years. GAO identified such a figure and the required breakdown in Castro’s proposal. The agency had relied in part on erroneous conclusions when choosing Guidehouse despite Castro’s lower bid. GAO found a reasonable possibility that a different evaluation could have changed the agency’s tradeoff.

Timing shaped the remedy. Guidehouse had performed the original term, and part of a subsequent six-month extension remained. The agency contended that stopping work would interfere with legally required reporting. GAO considered disruption impractical and recommended reimbursing Castro’s reasonable proposal and protest costs. It did not award the work to Castro or decide whether the agency had properly allowed the contract to continue during the protest.

The record shows why the result of a bid protest requires reading past the word sustained. The merits finding can identify procurement errors while the remedy responds to what can still be changed. Here, review of the award produced an official correction to the evaluation record and a recommendation about costs.

Source Documents

  1. GAO’s public bid protest decision
  2. GAO guide to bid protest decisions
Share by email Corrections policy

Related reporting