Antarctica contract protest asks whose experience counts on a federal bid
GAO found the National Science Foundation gave KBR credit for an affiliate without enough evidence that the affiliate’s resources would support the work.
A federal contract supporting American research in Antarctica depended in part on an ordinary procurement question. Could a bidder claim credit for a related company’s track record? The Government Accountability Office found that the National Science Foundation had insufficient support for doing so in one competition, and recommended a new award decision after a reevaluation.
The National Science Foundation selected KBR Services for Antarctic science and engineering support. Battelle Memorial Institute challenged the award on several grounds. The agency had counted the experience and past performance of a KBR affiliate in assessing the bidder’s capability. Its assessment mattered to the comparison of the companies’ experience in services such as laboratory and science support.
In its September 10 decision, GAO distinguished corporate connection from demonstrated involvement in the contract. A bidder may be able to use an affiliate’s experience when its proposal shows that the affiliate’s people, systems or other resources will actually take part in the work. GAO found the proposal’s references to general corporate participation too vague to supply that connection. Identifying the related entity and submitting company disclosure information did not establish what resources would be available for performance.
NSF argued that the relative ranking of other factors and KBR’s lower evaluated price made any error harmless. GAO read the agency’s own tradeoff differently. The related company’s record narrowed a gap favorable to Battelle. Correcting that evaluation could reasonably have improved Battelle’s competitive standing, which established the required possibility of prejudice. GAO rejected other parts of the protest.
The decision recommends a new evaluation of KBR’s experience and past performance, followed by a new selection decision and reimbursement of specified protest costs. It does not pick a contractor or suggest that corporate affiliates can never contribute to a bid. The lesson from the record is narrower: general organizational charts cannot substitute for describing how the relevant capabilities will be used.