Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Opinion analysis

Virginia appeals court sets causation standard for pregnancy-accommodation firing claims

The court said a pregnancy-related accommodation can be a motivating factor in a firing even when the employer identifies other reasons.

Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia.
Context photograph. dctim1 · CC BY-SA 2.0. See Image Credits.

The Court of Appeals of Virginia ruled on Nov. 4 that an employee challenging a firing under the state’s pregnancy-accommodation law does not have to show that using an accommodation was the decisive reason for the dismissal. The published opinion sent Chanda Waldenmaier’s case back to the Stafford County Circuit Court while leaving an evidence ruling in place.

Waldenmaier alleged DBDriven.net terminated her after she used a pregnancy-related accommodation allowing her to work remotely. The circuit court applied a but-for test, asking whether she would have been dismissed without using the accommodation, and granted the employer summary judgment. The employer disputed that use of the accommodation led to the termination.

Judge Lisa M. Lorish read the pregnancy-accommodation protection together with the Virginia Human Rights Act’s provision making pregnancy or related medical conditions an unlawful motivating factor in employment practices even when other factors are present. The court reasoned that protection for use of an accommodation is part of the chapter’s prohibition on pregnancy discrimination. The result is a different question for the circuit court on remand: whether the evidence, under the rules governing summary judgment, can support a conclusion that the accommodation contributed to the decision.

The court also upheld exclusion of a recording of a work call under a separate Virginia evidence statute. Correcting the causation standard did not undo that ruling. The appellate decision does not determine what motivated the company or establish that Waldenmaier was unlawfully fired. It directs the court to reconsider the case under the standard the Virginia statute requires.

Source Documents

  1. Published opinion of the Court of Appeals of Virginia (PDF)
  2. Virginia pregnancy accommodations statute, Va. Code § 2.2-3909
  3. Virginia unlawful discrimination practices, Va. Code § 2.2-3905
Share by email Corrections policy

Related reporting