Maryland court upholds search warrant after setting challenged observations aside
Maryland’s highest court considered whether independently obtained information would justify the warrant if the challenged police observations were left out.
The Supreme Court of Maryland affirmed three convictions from a Worcester County case after applying a rule for separating independently obtained information in a warrant application from information gathered in a challenged search. The Sept. 30 opinion in Founds v. State assumes for the analysis that police violated the Fourth Amendment during an earlier entry, while leaving the legality of that entry undecided.
Police had sought a warrant to search an apartment. The warrant papers included observations made during a preliminary sweep as well as other information. Andrew Campbell Founds argued the earlier search tainted the warrant and that evidence subsequently found should have been excluded. The trial court rejected the suppression motion, and the intermediate appellate court affirmed.
Justice Angela M. Eaves explained that under the independent-source doctrine a court can set aside the challenged material and ask whether the remaining facts objectively establish probable cause. The majority concluded the information acquired independently was enough for the search in this case. That conclusion does not authorize the earlier sweep. It explains why the court could resolve the evidentiary issue without ruling conclusively on that question.
The high court also reviewed whether the record supported the three possession convictions. It considered proximity, access, control over the location and evidence of shared use or benefit. Its opinion declined to hold that evidence of a drug operation alone makes a person responsible for everything found in a residence. The majority upheld the convictions on the combined record before it.
The decision makes the content of the warrant affidavit especially important. A court applying this doctrine looks closely at what investigators learned from an independent source and whether those facts supplied enough grounds for the warrant after the contested material was disregarded.