Virginia software contract dispute is sent to arbitration after federal removal
The court counted the value of requested contract relief for jurisdiction and found that the parties’ agreement delegated threshold disputes to the arbitrator.
A dispute over the software that a Virginia business bought will proceed in arbitration after a federal court denied a request to return the case to state court. U.S. District Judge Jamar K. Walker found Oct. 7 that Epicor Software established the amount needed for federal jurisdiction and that its contract with Riverside Paper Supply required arbitration.
Riverside claimed that Epicor’s software and services were commercially unacceptable and sought $64,713.21 in damages. The business also asked to void the contract. The damages figure alone fell below the more-than-$75,000 threshold for federal diversity jurisdiction. The court examined the economic value of the requested contract relief to the parties. It took account of future fees linked to the agreement, and separately concluded that recoverable attorney fees could bring the amount over the threshold. That calculation did not decide whether either party was ultimately entitled to recover those sums.
The court next examined who should decide whether the dispute fell within the arbitration agreement. Walker concluded that the contract’s language and its incorporation of the American Arbitration Association’s commercial rules gave the arbitrator that authority. The opinion also addressed Riverside’s argument in the alternative. Riverside said it was seeking a debt under a collection exception. The judge explained that the money was sought as a remedy for alleged breach, rather than as a fixed obligation to pay that amount set out in the agreement. The alleged fraud concerned the contract as a whole rather than fraud directed at the arbitration clause itself.
The court compelled arbitration and dismissed the action after noting that no party sought a stay while arbitration proceeded. It did not decide whether the software worked as promised or whether the contract should be voided. The decision shows why the requested remedy matters both at removal and in identifying the forum that will hear the dispute.