Norfolk judge leaves maritime equipment maker in dredging injury dispute
The court found factual disputes over a lever hoist’s design, warnings and foreseeable use. It also recognized a maritime route for seeking recovery of certain costs from a negligent third party.
A federal judge in Norfolk left an equipment-maker in a maritime dispute after a deckhand was injured while working aboard a dredging vessel. U.S. District Judge Elizabeth W. Hanes ruled Oct. 23 on a motion from lever-hoist manufacturer JPW Industries. She rejected two of the vessel operator’s theories but found that questions about warnings, design and any sharing of liability could not be fully resolved at summary judgment.
The litigation followed an injury during a dredge-pipe repair. The vessel operator, Cottrell Contracting, sought indemnity or contribution from JPW after the worker sued the operator. JPW argued that the alleged use fell outside the hoist’s intended purpose. The opinion explained that intended use is relevant without settling what uses a manufacturer could reasonably foresee. Evidence about the manual and design could support different conclusions about foreseeable use and whether an overload safeguard should have been included.
JPW also argued the manual warned adequately and that Cottrell could not show it had been read. Hanes found the wording about different binding applications left room for a fact-finder to disagree about whether the warnings were sufficient. She also found the evidence concerning a supervisor’s familiarity with the instructions did not settle whether he reviewed the manual. Cottrell conceded it was not pursuing a manufacturing defect and abandoned the warranty theory, so the judge granted judgment on those points.
The court also addressed a question peculiar to maritime law. Maintenance and cure generally refers to support and medical costs an employer owes a qualifying injured seafarer. Hanes adopted the view that a vessel owner can seek recovery of such payments from a third party whose negligence caused or contributed to the disability. That conclusion allows a recovery theory to proceed without establishing that JPW was negligent or owes the operator money.
The case separates two questions that can arise after an onboard injury: the employer’s duties to a worker and which third parties may ultimately share particular costs. This opinion leaves disputed facts concerning the accident and fault for further proceedings.