Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Opinion analysis

Richmond judge declines to compel Texas witness to appear in person in judgment dispute

A federal judge held that territorial subpoena limits still applied in a dispute over returning assets to satisfy a lending-case judgment, despite a modified bankruptcy stay.

Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia.
Context photograph. dctim1 · CC BY-SA 2.0. See Image Credits.

A Richmond federal judge declined to require Matthew Martorello to appear in person for a hearing over efforts to collect a judgment from a consumer-lending case. U.S. District Judge Robert E. Payne’s Oct. 7 opinion said the court would hear him remotely. The ruling addressed the place and method of testimony, leaving the separate dispute over foreign assets for the underlying proceedings.

The plaintiffs sought a hearing on their request to return assets they alleged had been placed abroad to frustrate collection. Martorello lives and works in Texas. Rule 45 ordinarily limits an in-person subpoena to a place within 100 miles of where a person resides, works or regularly transacts business, with a separate provision for qualifying attendance within the same state. Payne held those limits did not reach Martorello for attendance in Richmond.

The plaintiffs argued that the court’s inherent authority should reach farther because they alleged an effort to frustrate collection. The judge distinguished a case in which a court itself was investigating potential misconduct directed at the judicial process. He found that the plaintiffs’ request concerned the separate problem of recovering assets from an alleged effort to impede judgment creditors. He also concluded that credibility could be assessed remotely and observed that counsel could be present with Martorello in Texas to address issues with exhibits.

An order modifying the bankruptcy stay allowed the Virginia court to reach the asset proceeding within the terms set by the bankruptcy court. Payne found that the order removed a constraint imposed by the stay without supplying new authority to override Rule 45. The distinction matters in collection litigation involving more than one court. The ability to resume a proceeding does not by itself determine where a particular witness must appear.

The underlying motion’s outcome was not decided by the October opinion. Its broader point is that a federal court may preserve the opportunity to examine a witness while honoring territorial limits on requiring travel for an in-person appearance.

Source Documents

  1. Filed district court opinion, ECF No. 1699 (PDF)
  2. Court opinion text and docket metadata
  3. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, including Rule 45
  4. Bankruptcy automatic stay, 11 U.S.C. § 362
Share by email Corrections policy

Related reporting