McLean owners lose bid to count broader I-495 impacts in easement compensation
Virginia’s appeals court tied the additional damages inquiry to the specific temporary easement, rather than every effect of a highway expansion project.
A Virginia appeals court held that a McLean property owner could not use an eminent-domain case about a temporary construction easement to seek compensation for the broader effect of the Interstate 495 expansion. Chief Judge Marla Graff Decker wrote the published Nov. 10 opinion affirming the Fairfax County Circuit Court.
The Virginia Department of Transportation sought a narrow, temporary strip of the property for construction. The owners disputed the amount needed to compensate them and proposed expert testimony about the effects on the value of the rest of the parcel. Some of the expert’s analysis concerned the sound wall and proximity of new travel lanes, effects tied to the larger highway work.
The opinion treats the easement itself as the relevant taking. Under Virginia’s just-compensation rules, damages to the remainder must flow from the taking at issue. The owners argued that the statute allowed the evaluator to look to everything buyers and sellers would reasonably consider. The appeals court held that the market-value language did not eliminate the need to connect the claimed effect to the temporary easement. It also rejected recovery in this proceeding for effects shared by the public that did not flow from the taking.
The court left room for direct damage to the rest of a parcel from the way the government uses an easement. Its ruling instead sustained exclusion of evidence that measured losses associated with the broader project. The court also denied fees and costs. For properties alongside a public project, the distinction is between the neighborhood impact and the specific government action that gave rise to a claim for compensation.