Mediancer.com The DMV Federal Report

Federal Courts.
Government Accountability.
The DMV and Beyond.

Opinion analysis

Nuclear plant access rule decides Dominion disability-discrimination case

The Richmond court found a former Surry security officer lacked unescorted access authorization required for the position and did not present evidence that his disability caused his discharge.

Aerial view of the Pentagon in Arlington, Virginia.
Context photograph. U.S. Air Force Staff Sgt. Brittany A. Chase, Department of Defense · U.S. public domain. See Image Credits.

A federal judge granted Dominion Energy summary judgment in a disability-discrimination suit brought by a former nuclear security officer at the Surry Nuclear Power Plant. U.S. District Judge Roderick C. Young concluded on Oct. 29 that the officer could not perform the essential functions of the job without the unescorted access authorization required under Nuclear Regulatory Commission rules.

Avery Kirby alleged that Dominion terminated him because of post-traumatic stress disorder. The court record showed Dominion had known about the diagnosis for years, and that he previously retained unescorted access after reassessment. In the reassessment at issue, a third-party psychologist requested additional records and reported being unable to complete the necessary determination without them. Kirby disputed the significance of the additional requests. The judge found the record undisputed that he did not provide all of the requested material.

The opinion drew a distinction between clearance through a medical review and authorization to enter protected areas without an escort. The employer’s own medical review officer cleared Kirby for duty, but that determination did not resolve the separate access inquiry. Under the rule governing commercial nuclear plants, the court reasoned, Dominion could not simply bypass the outside assessment and restore authorization for a position that required it.

Young also examined the evidence about the reason for termination. The timing did not support an inference that Dominion acted because of the long-known diagnosis, and the court said the access problem remained a supported explanation even if the case moved beyond the initial elements of the discrimination claim. Kirby was entitled to challenge the accuracy or significance of the assessment, but the court found those disagreements did not create a trial question about the company’s stated reason on this record.

The opinion is limited to this role and the record of the authorization process. Its significance lies in how a federal job-access requirement can determine whether someone remains qualified for a specific position under the Americans with Disabilities Act. The court indicated a separate order would accompany its decision on the remaining count.

Source Documents

  1. Filed district court opinion, ECF No. 47 (PDF)
  2. Court opinion text and docket metadata
  3. NRC access authorization requirements, 10 C.F.R. § 73.56
  4. ADA employment discrimination provision, 42 U.S.C. § 12112
Share by email Corrections policy